Phish Setlist at Madison Square Garden, New York, NY, USA

1. Set 1:
2. Sunday Morning
   (The Velvet Underground cover) (Fish on lead vocals & Trey on drums; live debut by Phish)
   Play Video
3. Axilla
   Play Video
4. Your Pet Cat
   (>)
   Play Video
5. Back on the Train
   (with 'Streets of Cairo' tease by Trey)
   Play Video
6. How Many People Are You
   (Mike Gordon song)
   Play Video
7. Glide
   Play Video
8. Theme From the Bottom
   (>)
   Play Video
9. It's Ice
   (with 'Super Bad' tease by Trey) (>)
   Play Video
10. More
    Play Video
11. Set 2:
12. AC/DC Bag
    (>)
    Play Video
13. Wolfman's Brother
    (unfinished) (>)
    Play Video
14. Twist
    (>)
    Play Video
15. Waves
    (>)
    Play Video
16. Miss You
    Play Video
17. Boogie On Reggae Woman
    (Stevie Wonder cover)
    Play Video
18. Wading in the Velvet Sea
    Play Video
20. Encore:
21. Sweet Jane
    (The Velvet Underground cover) (first since 29 June 2012)
    Play Video

Note: This show was night three of Phish's Baker's Dozen run at Madison Square Garden and consisted of a red velvet donut theme; Red velvet donuts with cream cheese frosting were given to fans arriving at the venue; Fish came out on stage for 'Sunday Morning' wearing a stole and mitre. He also lifted a censer with burning incense at one point, and even sprinkled "holy water" on the crowd. The venue was draped in red lights for the "velvet" themed songs: 'Sunday Morning' and 'Sweet Jane' (both Velvet Underground covers) and Wading in the Velvet Sea.